b. Significance
of Time/Frequency Standard: Precise time/frequency measurement
is essential for telecommunications, broadcasting, military,
navigation, and other scientific experiments. For example.
a small time error of "one second" at a speed
of 17,580 miles per hour or 7860 m/s (this is the speed
at which the space shuttle travels in orbit) of space shuttle,
the target (say, docking with the space station) is missed
by about 7.8 kilometers! Of course, for applications where
the primary standard of frequency is not required, you have
secondary and tertiary standards available. The secondary,
and tertiary standards are traceable to the primary standard.
2. Important Types of Frequency Standards
- Cesium Standard (Primary standard)
- Rubidium Standard (Secondary standard)
- Crystal Standards (Tertiary standard, and below)
- Cesium (caesium) Standard: The cesium standard is the
primary standard of time/frequency. It is the standard maintained
by over 250+ atomic stations around the world for keeping
the UTC. The commercially available primary standards have
an accuracy of ± 1 in 10 11.
- Rubidium Standard: Rubidium is known as the secondary
standard for time/frequency. The standard is calibrated
using primary standard. Commercially available rubidium
standards have a stability of about ± 5 in 1011.
Note that both Cesium and Rubidium are atomic standards
and exhibit extremely high accuracy and ageing characteristics.
- Crystal Standards: Normally, crystal standards provide
stability of the order of 1 in 108. The crystal
standards are comparatively cheap, and available in various
forms depending on the accuracy level required. As a result,
crystal standards are widely used in test and measurement
equipment, and telecom. Quartz is primarily used for making
crystal oscillator standards. The material exhibits high
Q, and higher stiffness (resulting in smaller Capacitance
value, and low loss).
Crystal Oscillators may be further sub-divided into three
broad categories. These are:
XO is short for Crystal Oscillator. Ordinary crystal oscillators
exhibit high rates of inaccuracy, and ageing. These are normally
used in applications that do not require high accuracies, or
in conjunction with more stable oscillator source such as a
TCXO. TCXO stands for Temperature Controlled Crystal Oscillator.
TCXOs' exhibit relatively more stable accuracy, and ageing characteristics.
TCXOs are widely used in telecom equipment for providing stable
source of frequencies. OCXO stands for Oven Controlled Crystal
Oscillator. OCXOs are considered to be the most stable among
crystal oscillators. Oven oscillators take a few minutes to
warm-up and the power consumption is typically few watts at
room temperature.
3. Comparison of Time/Frequency Standards
Important parameters that characterize a frequency/time standard
are:
a. Frequency Accuracy
b. Ageing
c. Phase Noise
d. Warm-up time
e. Temperature Stability
|
Cesium |
Rubidium |
OCXO (typical) |
Frequency Accuracy |
5E-13 |
1.0E-11 |
1.0E-9 |
Ageing |
Better than 1 x 1.0E-14 |
<5.0E-11/month |
5.0E-11 per day |
Phase Noise |
-130dBc at 10Hz |
-90dBc at 10Hz |
-140dBc at 10Hz |
Warm-up time |
<10 min, and may take up to 48 hrs to attain
full accuracy levels. |
30 Min |
30 Min |
Stability |
1.0E-14 |
<3.0E-11 |
1.0E-12 |
Remarks |
Excellent stability |
Good stability, and cheaper than cesium. |
Cheap, good phase noise. Poor accuracy, and
ageing characteristics. |
Note that the values shown above are only typical, and you
need to consult the manufacturer product datasheet before making
any purchase. As seen in the table above, crystal oscillators
exhibit good stability, but poor accuracy. Further, crystal
oscillators require initial burn-in (this to accommodate initial
frequency drift associated with crystal oscillators).
4. Definition
of terms:
Frequency Accuracy: This is the degree of conformity
to a specified value of a frequency. It is usually represented
by the offset from the ideal frequency with zero uncertainty.
Ageing: Ageing is the process during which the frequency
changes permanently. Ageing occurs primarily due to stress relief,
and is structurally related. For quartz crystals, ageing is
quicker during the initial period. For this reason, quartz crystal
oscillators are aged before final manufacture and shipment.
Phase Noise: Phase noise is the random frequency fluctuation
of the signal. Phase noise is normally measured at 1Hz, 10Hz,
100Hz, 3kHz, etc. from the carrier. Lower values are desirable
(say -100dBc is better than -80dBc). The oscillator phase noise
is a significant parameter, since it used to modulate the signal
frequencies and ultimately affect the purity of the transmitted/received
signal.
Warm-up time: Warm-up time is the amount of time an
un-powered electronic device at room temperature takes to stabilize
at its higher operating temperature once it has been powered
on.
Stability: Oscillators frequency stability is defined
as the measure of the degree to which an oscillator maintains
the same value of frequency over a given time. Atomic frequency
sources, such as cesium and rubidium are very stable. The stability
of crystal oscillators can be improved by using TCXO's and OCXO's.
5. Manufacturers of Frequency/Time Standards:
A. Cesium Standards:
- .Symmetricom, Inc. www. symmetricom.com
B. Rubidium Standards:
- .Symmetricom, Inc., USA www. symmetricom.com
- .Novatech Instruments, Inc., USA www.novatech-instr.com
C. Crystal Oscillators:
- .Symmetricom, Inc., USA www. symmetricom.com
- .Symmetricom, Inc., USA www. symmetricom.com
- .Novatech Instruments, Inc., USA www.novatech-instr.com
- .Bliley Technologies, Inc., www.bliley.com
- .Spectracom Corporation, NY, USA, www.spectracomcorp.com
D. Hydrogen Maser Standards
- .Quartzlock (UK) Ltd. www.quartzlock.com
- .Symmetricom, Inc., USA www. Symmetricom.com
6. References:
https://tf.nist.gov/timefreq/general/precision.htm#Anchor-29509
https://www.ieee-uffc.org/freqcontrol/quartz/vig/vigtoc.htm